I've found a reoccurring theme, every time I've tested this out - no matter what city, state.
Without selecting any filter criteria, I entered Clifton, NJ, USA dog boarding search ...and kept scrolling through the pages at the bottom.
After seeing over 200 pages (with 20 sitters per page) appear, with sitters that I think we'd agree are not in or close to your city (and not even in your state), I got disgusted and quit clicking. A pet parent seeking care would have done so long before that point.
I saw your boarding rate is 50. Applause for choosing a rate that shows you value the care you give! Then I edited the search to only show boarding between $50-150...(drum roll) ... 90 pages appeared. ...
If I repeatedly use to + sign to zoom into the map down to the street level, that's the only way to see only 1 page of 20 sitters!
I do not see how this search functionality could possibly be what the dog people want or need. Please understand I'm not shouting at you, it just must be so frustrating for pet parents to have to sift through so many profiles to find the right match.